Homemade Circus Animal Cookies

Pin It

Homemade Circus Animal Cookies

The other day I decided to make my own circus animal cookies. Here’s how you do it:

  • Bake a batch of sugar cookies.
    • Use a mini cookie cutter, about 1.5 – 2″ in diameter.
  • Dip baked cookies into melted almond bark.
  • Cover with sprinkles.

I love making (and eating) sugar cookies, and these circus animal cookies were a fun variation. These would make an excellent neighbor or just-thinking-about-you gift.

40 thoughts on “Homemade Circus Animal Cookies”

  1. Hey! You totally got mentioned on Crafty Crow (belladia.typepad.com/crafty_crow/)!!!

    I went to see if there was anything new that I had to bookmark for later … and then I’m all “Oh Em Gee!!! I KNOW her!!!!!!” — Kinda like Will Ferrell in Elf. ^_^

    But, yay! You’re famous!!

    And the cookies look delicious, too.

    Reply
  2. These look delicious…and how simple! I truly go through a whole bag of these easily when we buy them at the store. I don’t know if I am brave enough to make these at home – and not eat all of them!

    Reply
  3. i know we just met, well, okay, we haven’t, but i found you through kirtsy and hi, nice to meet you, anyhoo, i am officially in LOVE with you for this idea. i will be making these soon! (and didya know, williams sonoma has animal cracker cookie cutters. i’m gonna splurge i think.) you’re fab! thanks!

    Reply
  4. I’ll be baking these for sure! I love frosted animal crackers and can now make my own whenever the urge hits me to have some on hand all the time! YUMMMMM

    Reply
  5. I eat the storebought frosted animal cookies by the handful. Should I or should I not make this homemade version and risk my waistline? Oh man, those look good.

    Reply
  6. My parents must have purchased the cheap brand of animal cookies…no frosting! And I have to admit I don’t know what almond bark is, but it looks good! Can someone give me a hint? Sprinkles I got!
    Thanks!

    Reply
  7. those look amazing. I am soo going to make them and give them as a treat to my kids! We were just talkinga bout this wonderful cookies at church the other day. Would you dye the almond bark to get pink ones?

    Reply
  8. What cute little cookies! I have everything you said I need – I stock up on almond bark at the beginning of the holiday season to make chocolate covered pecans and pretzels as gifts. These cookies would be fun to make with the kids and as you said, make great gifts – maybe even a baggie full of them for birthday party favors! Thanks for the recipe and instructions.

    Reply
  9. I made these over the weekend using your recipe because my hubby and kids are huge fans. I was suprised at how much they actually do taste like the real thing. They were a big hit. I just found your blog and will definetly become a follower. I hope you don’t mind me linking to this post from my blog. Thanks!!

    Reply
  10. Our 3y/o son is going through 2 distinct phases right now. One is that he loves to help with things, such as helping to prepare food. The other phase is that he begs for animal cookies with icing every day.

    I had never thought about us making our own, but I bet he will like them twice as much (if that’s possible) if we let him help mix the dough and add the sprinkles :)

    Reply
  11. Wow, I would have never thought of trying to make these myself. But now that you suggested it I will try it out because my daughter thinks that I only get cookies from the freezer and can’t make them like her friend’s mom with real butter. Love your site so I am signing up right now! How fun are you?!

    Reply
  12. Thank you so much for the great recipe! I just have a quick question. What is the easiest way to dip these? Do you dip the front then the back? Please give me any tips you have. Thanks again.

    Reply
  13. 2 c shortening
    3 c sugar
    1 t vanilla
    1 t almond extract
    1 t nutmeg
    Add:
    4 eggs beaten well and slowly mix in
    6-7 c flour

    Dough will be stiff and dry like pie dough.
    Roll out about 1/3″ thick, cut into shapes.
    Bake 10 m. or less at 400. Do not let edges

    Reply
  14. Jennifer, to answer your question about the easiest way to dip, I throw a handful of them in and pull them out one by one with a fork. The excess chocolate drips through the fork and then I scrape the bottom of the fork on the edge of the bowl to get off even more.

    Enjoy!

    Reply

Leave a Comment